Johnson wins in squeaker of an election

After Vance held a lead through Monday, Johnson pulled ahead with just 59 votes.

Brent Johnson, right, speaks at a candidate forum for the Alaska House District 6 Representative race on Wednesday, Sept. 16, at Kachemak Bay Campus. (Daniel Zatz/HIP)

The blue electoral wave made it to Homer after all this week, washing into town two weeks after the national election as independent candidate Brent Johnson of Clam Gulch defeated four-term incumbent Rep. Sarah Vance, a Republican, for the House District 6 seat.

On election night, Vance led Johnson by 210 votes. But a strong showing from early and absentee ballots finally moved Johnson ahead this week, with a final margin Wednesday night of 59 votes.

Johnson’s election marks a sea change in Southern Kenai Peninsula politics. He’s the first Independent elected for the district since statehood, and the first local non-Republican since Libertarian Andre Marrou, who served from 1985-87. Democrats Mike Navarre of Kenai (1985-93) and C.E. Swackhammer of Soldotna (1987-90) also represented the area before redistricting.

A person holds a sign for Brent Johnson, a nonpartisan candidate seeking to unseat incumbent Rep. Sarah Vance, R-Homer, on Primary Election Day, Aug. 18, in Homer. (Michael Armstrong/HIP)

As more absentee and early-voting ballots got counted, Vance saw her lead drop to just 13 votes on Friday the 13th. On Monday, her lead stretched to 18, but a big batch of absentee ballots on Tuesday pushed Johnson ahead for good. In final but still unofficial results, Johnson had 5,088 votes to 5,029 for Vance. District 6 voters had a 56.1% turnout.


Brent Johnson smiles after finishing the Run for Recovery on Aug. 29, 2026, on the Homer Spit in Homer, Alaska. (Michael Armstrong/HIP)

Vance conceded the election in a Facebook post from her Vote Vance page.

“Congratulations goes to Brent Johnson for winning the election by 59 votes,” she wrote. “… All praise and glory goes to Jesus for His grace to serve you these last 4 terms. Thank you to every voter and volunteer for your hard work in this campaign. I may not hold the office this next term, but I will never stop representing you.”

Rep. Sarah Vance, R-Homer, introduces Rep. Nick Begich III, R-Alaska, at a meet-and-greet for him on Monday, Oct. 26, at Captain’s Coffee in Homer. (Michael Armstrong/HIP)

Vance repeated most of those sentiments in a follow-up conversation Wednesday night.

“It’s obviously a bit of a surprise … I knew it’d be close, but I am surprised that I didn’t win,” she said. “However, I know that Brent ran a strong ground game, and I just appreciate everyone for getting out to vote.”

She said she “will be assessing” her path going forward.

“I know that my job in government isn’t over. There is a lot of good work that is left undone. I’m not going anywhere,” she said.

Johnson was traveling to Anchorage on Wednesday evening and not available for comment.

In the August primary, Johnson had 2,940 votes or 55% to 2,406 votes or 45% for Vance. Vance mounted a campaign heavy on radio ads, spending nearly $35,000. In contrast, Johnson spent mostly on office staff, campaign signs and newspaper ads.

Vance said she campaigned heavily in district communities, including the Russian Old Believer villages.

“I made sure I did a lot more voter education this time, and I think that paid off well. Obviously it wasn’t quite enough, but we had an excellent turnout in our district,” she said.

In the total vote for both candidates, the number from the primary nearly doubled, from 5,346 to 10,117. Vance had the greatest gain, but it wasn’t enough.

Johnson picked up votes from early-voting and absentee votes. While Vance won decisively in election night totals in the Anchor Point, Fox River, Homer No. 2, Kasilof and Ninilchik precincts, Johnson led with 62% of district-wide early-voting and 56% in absentee voting. He also won in the Diamond Ridge, Homer No. 1, Kachemak City-Fritz Creek and Seldovia-Kachemak Bay precincts.

Because early-voting and absentee ballots aren’t sorted out by precincts, the by-precinct numbers are skewed. Progressives had encouraged early voting, including at a No Kings get-out-the-vote rally held in late October.

Johnson’s victory ends a decades-long domination of the Southern Kenai Peninsula House seat by Republicans. Vance won election in 2018, defeating former Rep. Paul Seaton, who ran then as a nonpartisan candidate. Seaton had previously won election as a Republican over fellow Republican Drew Scalzi.

The southern peninsula has had only four representatives who were not Republican: Democrats Hugh Malone,1973-1985; Mike Navarre, 1985-93; and C.E. Swackhammer, 1987-1990, and Libertarian Andre Marrou, 1985-1987. In that era, House districts had two representatives.

Republican Leo Rhode was Homer’s first representative, followed by Republican Clem Tillion.

Homer was the longtime stronghold of Republican Gail Phillips, who at one point served as Speaker of the House.

Reporter Delcenia Cosman contributed to this story.

Discover more from The Homer Independent Press

Subscribe to get the latest stories sent to your email.

Subscribe for FREE to get HIP!

Get weekly newsletters and breaking news sent to your inbox

(after you hit "subscribe," check your inbox to confirm your email address)

We don’t spam! Read more in our Privacy Policy

Leave a Reply