Seldovia flips coin for new council member

Heads, you win. Tails, you lose.

Harmony Payton (left) and Kelsey Sandera pose for a photo after the Seldovia City Council certifies election results during a special meeting on Monday, Nov. 16, in Seldovia. (Photo provided)

The election of Seldovia’s second city council member was left to chance after two write-in candidates repeatedly tied.

Kelsey Sandera won election by a coin toss during a special meeting Monday.

Volunteer election judge Jenny Chissus drew a name out of a metaphorical hat — in this event, a tin can — to determine which candidate would call their side of the coin. The other write-in candidate, John Kennedy, won that lottery and picked tails.

Seldovia election officials determine the winner of the second City Council seat by coin toss during a special meeting on Monday, Nov. 16, 2026, in Seldovia, Alaska. (Photo provided)

Fellow election judge Kathy Giles tossed the coin. It landed heads up for Sandera.

Four candidates ran for two council seats belonging to incumbents Harmony Payton and Meggie Landvardt. Payton easily retained her seat; Landvardt did not seek reelection.

Sandera and Kennedy, both certified write-in candidates, each received 30 votes after election officials tallied absentee ballots on Nov. 9. Teela Bright received 22 votes.

The Canvass Board held a recount on Nov. 11. Bright’s tally stayed the same; Sandera and Kennedy each received one more vote, tying them at 31 votes apiece.

Unofficial election results show a persistent tie between Seldovia City Council candidates John Kennedy and Kelsey Sandera after a recount on Nov. 11. (Photo provided)

Seldovia Municipal Code says the winner between tied candidates is determined by lot. City clerk Liz Diament said the State of Alaska recognizes coin flipping or drawing straws as valid tiebreaking methods.

City manager Heidi Geagel said Seldovia hasn’t needed to resort to a tiebreaker in recent election history.

“It’s certainly unprecedented in the last couple of decades,” she said.

While uncommon, determining the winner of an election by lot isn’t unheard of in Alaska or other states. In 2006, Rep. Bryce Edgmon, I-Dillingham, defeated the House District 37 incumbent by coin toss in the primary election. In 2017, a Virginia House race was determined by drawing names out of a container.

Sandera and Payton will be sworn in at the next Seldovia City Council meeting on Monday, Nov. 23. Mayor Jeremiah Campbell, who ran unopposed, also will be sworn in.

Unofficial results for the City of Seldovia municipal election on Nov. 3. (Photo provided)

Discover more from The Homer Independent Press

Subscribe to get the latest stories sent to your email.

Subscribe for FREE to get HIP!

Get weekly newsletters and breaking news sent to your inbox

(after you hit "subscribe," check your inbox to confirm your email address)

We don’t spam! Read more in our Privacy Policy

Leave a Reply